Skip to content

Making the Switch: 403b Rollover vs 401k – Which One is Right for You?

by Team Enrichest on

Are you ready to level up your retirement savings game? Well, buckle up because we're about to dive into the world of 403b rollovers and 401ks. Now, before you start feeling overwhelmed by all the numbers and jargon, take a deep breath. We're here to break it down for you in simple, human terms.

So, let's tackle the age-old question: should you stick with your trusty 403b or make the switch to a snazzy 401k? Don't worry, we've got your back and we'll help you figure out which one is right for you. Let's get this rollover party started!

Understanding 403b Rollover and 401k

What is a 403b Rollover?

A 403b rollover refers to the process of transferring funds from a 403b retirement plan to another eligible retirement account, such as a 401k. It allows individuals to consolidate their retirement savings into a single account, providing potential benefits like greater investment options and ease of management. Here's what you need to know about a 403b rollover:

  • A 403b rollover allows you to move your existing retirement funds to a new account.
  • It provides the opportunity to take advantage of potentially better investment options and lower fees.
  • The rollover process involves completing necessary paperwork, selecting a new account, and transferring the funds.
  • It enables individuals to maintain tax-deferred status, as long as the funds are transferred directly between the accounts.
  • Before deciding to initiate a 403b rollover, it's important to carefully consider your retirement goals, investment preferences, and evaluate the features and benefits of the new retirement account.

What is a 401k?

A 401k is a retirement savings plan offered by many private sector employers. Here's a concise overview of what a 401k entails:

  • It allows employees to contribute a portion of their pre-tax salary towards retirement savings.
  • The contributions grow tax-deferred until withdrawal during retirement.
  • Employers often match a percentage of the employee's contributions, which can significantly boost savings.
  • The contribution limits for 401k plans are set by the IRS and may change over time.
  • 401k plans offer a range of investment options, allowing individuals to choose from stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and more.

Differences between 403b Rollover and 401k

Eligibility and Availability

To initiate a 403b rollover, it’s crucial to understand the eligibility and availability criteria. Generally, individuals who work in educational institutions, hospitals, or non-profit organizations can participate in a 403b plan. However, not all employers offer this option, so availability may vary depending on your workplace.

For example, if you're employed by a public school, you should have access to a 403b plan, whereas employees of private companies may have a 401k instead. Make sure to check with your employer to determine the specific retirement plan they offer. Remember, eligibility and availability are fundamental factors when considering a 403b rollover.

Contributions and Contribution Limitations

Contributions to a 403b rollover and a 401k are subject to certain limitations. These limitations determine the maximum amount an individual can contribute to their retirement account each year. While both plans have contribution limits set by the IRS, they differ slightly:

  • 403b Rollover Contribution Limit: The current annual contribution limit for a 403b rollover is $19,500 (as of 2021). However, individuals who are age 50 or older can make catch-up contributions of up to $6,500, bringing their total contribution limit to $26,000.
  • 401k Contribution Limit: The contribution limit for a 401k is also $19,500 per year. However, individuals aged 50 and above can make catch-up contributions of $6,500, reaching a total limit of $26,000.

It's important to note that both contribution limits apply to the combined total of contributions made to all retirement accounts in a given year. It's essential to understand these limitations to make informed decisions about how much to contribute to your retirement savings.

Investment Options

  • When considering a 403b rollover, it's important to assess the investment options available in a 401k.
  • 401k plans often offer a diverse range of investment choices, including mutual funds, index funds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), and sometimes even company stock.
  • These options provide investors with the opportunity to diversify their portfolio and tailor it to their risk tolerance and investment goals.
  • With a 401k, you have the flexibility to allocate your funds across different asset classes and investment strategies.
  • It's crucial to carefully review the investment options offered by the potential 401k provider and ensure they align with your investment preferences and long-term financial objectives.
  • Consider factors such as expense ratios, historical performance, and the fund's investment philosophy before making a decision.

Employer Matching Contributions

Employer matching contributions play a significant role in retirement planning when considering a 403b rollover. By transferring your funds to a 401k, you may be able to take advantage of a higher employer matching contribution.

For example, if your current employer matches 50% of your 403b contributions, but another employer matches 100% of your 401k contributions, the rollover could potentially double your employer's contribution. This can result in substantial growth of your retirement savings over time. Therefore, carefully evaluate the matching contribution options of your prospective 401k plan when deciding whether a 403b rollover is right for you.

Vesting Period

The vesting period refers to the amount of time an employee must work for an organization before gaining full ownership of employer contributions in their retirement account. In the context of a 403b rollover, understanding the vesting period is crucial. Different employers have varying policies, with some offering immediate vesting while others may require several years of service. If you're considering a rollover from a 403b to a 401k, it's important to take into account the vesting period of your current and potential new employer's plan. This will determine how much ownership you have over your employer's contributions and impact your retirement savings if you switch employers before becoming fully vested.

Withdrawals and Penalties

Withdrawals from a 403b rollover or a 401k are subject to specific rules and penalties. Generally, if you withdraw funds before reaching the age of 59.5, you may face a 10% early withdrawal penalty in addition to income taxes. However, there are exceptions to this penalty, such as qualifying for a financial hardship or disability. It's important to understand these rules before making any withdrawals to avoid unnecessary fees.

For example, if you need to access funds for medical expenses, you can withdraw without penalties. Always consult the plan documents or speak with a financial advisor to determine the specific withdrawal rules and potential penalties for your 403b rollover or 401k.

Rollover Options and Flexibility

Rollover options and flexibility are important factors to consider when deciding between a 403b rollover and a 401k. With a 403b rollover, you have the option to transfer your funds into another qualified retirement account, such as an Individual Retirement Account (IRA) or a new employer's retirement plan like a 401k. This provides flexibility in managing your investments and potentially accessing a wider range of investment options.

Additionally, the 403b rollover allows you to consolidate your retirement savings into one account, making it easier to track and manage. It's crucial to research and compare the rollover options offered by different financial institutions or employers to ensure they align with your investment goals and preferences.

Fees and Expenses

When considering a 403b rollover, it is crucial to evaluate the fees and expenses associated with the new 401k plan. These costs can significantly impact the growth of your retirement savings over time. Look for plans with low expense ratios and administrative fees to maximize your returns. Compare investment options and their associated fees to find the ones that align with your investment goals.

For example, index funds often have lower fees compared to actively managed funds.

Additionally, consider any potential charges for account maintenance, transactions, or early withdrawals. Understanding and minimizing these fees will help you optimize your retirement savings.

Determining the Right Choice

Factors to Consider

  • Employment situation: Assess if you plan to change jobs soon or have job stability. If you are changing positions, consider the rollover process and if your new employer offers a 401k.
  • Investment preferences: Evaluate the investment options and flexibility offered by both plans. Determine if you prefer a diverse range of investment choices or if you are comfortable with limited options.
  • Retirement goals and timeline: Consider your retirement goals and how a 403b rollover or a 401k can align with them. Assess the contribution limits and see which plan helps you achieve your retirement goals within your desired timeframe.
  • Evaluation of current plan: Analyze the fees, expenses, and performance of your current plan. Compare it with the potential benefits and costs of a 403b rollover or a 401k.
  • Consultation with a financial advisor: Seek advice from a financial advisor who can provide personalized guidance based on your specific financial situation, goals, and risk tolerance. They can assist in making an informed decision about whether a 403b rollover or a 401k is the right choice for you.

Your Employment Situation

Your current employment situation is a significant factor in determining whether a 403b rollover or a 401k is the right choice for you. If you plan to switch jobs in the near future, it may be more advantageous to roll over your 403b into a 401k offered by your new employer. This allows you to consolidate your retirement savings and manage them more efficiently.

On the other hand, if you anticipate staying with your current employer for the long term, it might be beneficial to keep your 403b and continue contributing to it.

Additionally, consider factors such as vesting periods and employer matching contributions when evaluating your employment situation.

Investment Preferences

  • Consider your investment preferences when deciding between a 403b rollover and a 401k.
  • Evaluate the investment options available in each plan and determine which aligns with your risk tolerance, desired asset allocation, and investment strategies.
  • If you prefer a wider range of investment choices, a 401k may offer more flexibility compared to a 403b, which is typically limited to investments with a focus on tax-exempt organizations.
  • On the other hand, if you prioritize socially responsible investing, some 403b plans may offer options that align with your values.
  • Always research and compare the investment options and associated fees in both plans to ensure they meet your investment preferences.

Retirement Goals and Timeline

Retirement goals and timeline are crucial factors to consider when deciding between a 403b rollover and a 401k. Assessing your desired lifestyle during retirement, the age at which you plan to retire, and the amount of money you anticipate needing are all important considerations. For instance, if you plan to retire early and require immediate access to your funds, a 401k may be more suitable due to its flexible withdrawal options.

On the other hand, if you have a long-term retirement plan and can wait until age 59 ½ to access your funds penalty-free, a 403b rollover may offer advantages such as tax-deferred growth. Consider your retirement goals and timeline carefully before making a decision.

Evaluation of Current Plan

When evaluating your current plan before considering a 403b rollover, it's important to assess the performance and fees associated with your existing 401k. Compare the investment options, historical returns, and expense ratios with industry benchmarks. Look at any administrative fees, account maintenance charges, or hidden costs that may erode your savings over time.

Additionally, consider the level of customer service and online account management tools offered by your current provider. By conducting a thorough evaluation, you can determine whether a 403b rollover would provide better investment options, lower fees, and improved services for your retirement savings.

Consultation with a Financial Advisor

  • Seek guidance from a qualified financial advisor to navigate the complexities of a 403b rollover.
  • An advisor can provide personalized insights and recommendations tailored to your specific financial situation and goals.
  • They can evaluate the available 401k options, considering factors like investment choices, fees, and employer contributions.
  • A financial advisor can help you understand the potential tax implications and guide you through the rollover process.
  • They can help you analyze the long-term impact of your decision and ensure it aligns with your retirement objectives. Remember, their expertise can provide valuable guidance in making informed choices for your financial future.

Process of a 403b Rollover to a 401k

Understanding the Rollover Process

  • Familiarize yourself with the rules and regulations surrounding a 403b rollover to a 401k.
  • Research the specific requirements and paperwork involved in the rollover process.
  • Contact your current 403b plan administrator to initiate the rollover and obtain necessary forms.
  • Complete the required paperwork accurately and ensure all details are provided.
  • Follow any specific instructions provided by both the 403b and 401k plan administrators.
  • Be aware of any fees or taxes associated with the rollover and consider potential implications on your retirement savings.
  • Keep track of the progress and confirm the successful completion of the rollover process with the 401k plan administrator.

Deciding to Rollover

Deciding whether to do a 403b rollover requires careful consideration. Evaluate your reasons for making the switch, such as seeking better investment options, lower fees, or consolidation of retirement savings. Assess the benefits and drawbacks of both your current 403b plan and the prospective 401k plan. Consider factors like employer matching contributions, vesting periods, and withdrawal penalties.

Consult a financial advisor to determine the best course of action based on your specific circumstances. Take time to research and compare 401k options to ensure they align with your investment preferences and long-term retirement goals.

Exploring 401k Options

Exploring 401k options is an important step when considering a 403b rollover. Take the time to research and compare the available investment options offered by different 401k plans. Look for a plan that aligns with your investment preferences and risk tolerance. Consider factors such as the variety of investment funds, the fees associated with the plan, and the performance history of the funds offered.

Additionally, pay attention to any limitations or restrictions on investment choices. This exploration process will help you make an informed decision and ensure that your rollover funds are invested in a manner that aligns with your long-term financial goals.

Complete Rollover Procedure

To complete a 403b rollover to a 401k, follow these simple steps.

First, review the terms and conditions of your 401k plan, ensuring it accepts rollovers. Then, obtain the necessary forms from your 401k provider. Fill them out accurately, providing all required information.

Next, initiate the rollover process by contacting your 403b plan administrator and requesting a direct rollover to your new 401k. Once the funds are transferred, confirm their arrival with your 401k provider and ensure they are properly allocated according to your investment preferences.

Finally, monitor your new 401k account to ensure a successful rollover and make any necessary adjustments to align with your retirement goals.


When considering switching from a 403b plan to a 401k plan, it's important to understand the key differences and consider your individual needs. A 403b plan is typically offered by tax-exempt organizations like schools or non-profits, while a 401k plan is commonly provided by for-profit companies. Some factors to consider include investment options, fees, contribution limits, and employer match.

It may be beneficial to consult with a financial advisor to determine which plan suits you best based on your goals, employment situation, and retirement savings strategy.